This is my third assignment in Management Information systems and the question is about assessing the implementation of e-government applications in the Philippines and my personal view and experience in it. If its succesful and if the objective was achieved. So what comes into my mind was the 2010 elections. A classic example. May 2010 elections to in the
Philippine history should be considered to be one of the giant leap done by the
Philippine government when it comes to accepting change as a transition
from manual to “partially” automated election. I am not fond of having political
arguments nor I see myself yet as an old-timer having afternoon coffee at
coffee shops discussing never ending politics with comrades but
nevertheless, lets grab the bull by its horn.
Philippine history should be considered to be one of the giant leap done by the
Philippine government when it comes to accepting change as a transition
from manual to “partially” automated election. I am not fond of having political
arguments nor I see myself yet as an old-timer having afternoon coffee at
coffee shops discussing never ending politics with comrades but
nevertheless, lets grab the bull by its horn.
If I remember it correctly, it was the times when many parties oppose the said “transition” including UP Law professor Harry Roque and Concerned Citizens Movement (CCM) stating that Republic Act 9369 (law amending the Poll Modernization Act or RA 8436) mandates Comelec to pilot test poll automation first by holding it in selected cities and provinces only for the coming national and local
elections. A closer reading of RA 9369 will show that Roque and CCM are merely
acting as proponents of the rule of law.
elections. A closer reading of RA 9369 will show that Roque and CCM are merely
acting as proponents of the rule of law.
To further understand the “transition” from manual to automated
election, SEC. 6. Section 6 of Republic Act No. 8436 is hereby amended to read
as follows:
election, SEC. 6. Section 6 of Republic Act No. 8436 is hereby amended to read
as follows:
"SEC. 5 Authority to Use an Automated Election System.
- To carry out the above-stated policy, the Commission on Elections, herein referred to as the Commission, is hereby authorized to use an automated
election system or systems in the same election in different provinces, whether
paper-based or a direct recording electronic election system as it may deem
appropriate and practical for the process of voting, counting of votes and
canvassing/consolidation and transmittal of results of electoral exercises: Provided, that for the
regular national and local election, which shall be held immediately after
effectivity of this Act, the AES shall be used in at least two highly urbanized
cities and two provinces each in Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao, to be chosen by the Commission: Provided, further, That local government units whose officials have been the subject of administrative charges within sixteen (16) month prior to the May 14, 2007 election shall not
be chosen: Provided, finally, That no area shall be chosen without the consent
of the Sanggunian of the local government unit concerned. The term local
government unit as used in this provision shall refer to a highly urbanized
city or province. In succeeding regular national or local elections, the AES
shall be implemented nationwide."
election system or systems in the same election in different provinces, whether
paper-based or a direct recording electronic election system as it may deem
appropriate and practical for the process of voting, counting of votes and
canvassing/consolidation and transmittal of results of electoral exercises: Provided, that for the
regular national and local election, which shall be held immediately after
effectivity of this Act, the AES shall be used in at least two highly urbanized
cities and two provinces each in Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao, to be chosen by the Commission: Provided, further, That local government units whose officials have been the subject of administrative charges within sixteen (16) month prior to the May 14, 2007 election shall not
be chosen: Provided, finally, That no area shall be chosen without the consent
of the Sanggunian of the local government unit concerned. The term local
government unit as used in this provision shall refer to a highly urbanized
city or province. In succeeding regular national or local elections, the AES
shall be implemented nationwide."
Now, i dont want to burden you guys and let you dashing for your collective memory of your law subject during college days but it doesnt take a genius to understand what is stated in the provision of the said law.
So much argument have risen from this modernization of our election that if we look closely in
the provision it only states that the said automation is not
national in coverage and in fact only two cities are required as minimum for it to be considered as automation. In other words, the amendatory law mandates comelec to conduct automated elections in 2010 in certain selected areas only. It may be argued that the word "at least" in section 6 authorizes Comelec to hold automated elections in more than two cities and provinces as
such phrase only sets the minimum. And more than two could practically mean
covering all cities and provinces in the country which would in fact make
automation nationwide. But that would be reading into the law something not
contemplated by it. First, that would mean requiring the consent of the Sanggunian
of every city and province in the country, which is of course ridiculous
for why would the law prescribe such consent requirement if after all every
city and province would be involved. Besides, the provinces and cities could
clearly defeat automation by withholding consent. Second, a nationwide
automation is clearly not contemplated by limiting it to cities and provinces
whose officials have not been subjected to administrative charges before the
2007 elections.
the provision it only states that the said automation is not
national in coverage and in fact only two cities are required as minimum for it to be considered as automation. In other words, the amendatory law mandates comelec to conduct automated elections in 2010 in certain selected areas only. It may be argued that the word "at least" in section 6 authorizes Comelec to hold automated elections in more than two cities and provinces as
such phrase only sets the minimum. And more than two could practically mean
covering all cities and provinces in the country which would in fact make
automation nationwide. But that would be reading into the law something not
contemplated by it. First, that would mean requiring the consent of the Sanggunian
of every city and province in the country, which is of course ridiculous
for why would the law prescribe such consent requirement if after all every
city and province would be involved. Besides, the provinces and cities could
clearly defeat automation by withholding consent. Second, a nationwide
automation is clearly not contemplated by limiting it to cities and provinces
whose officials have not been subjected to administrative charges before the
2007 elections.
It is very confusing in nature indeed that this so-called automation in the end
is a hybrid election which is part manual and part automated. If asked if it has achieved its main
objective, then I'd say NO. But of course we should also trust government that they will be prepared for the next election and whatever shortcomings that was encountered in 2010 elections, then
those will serve as learning process which will eventually pave the way for an
honest, fully automated elections.
is a hybrid election which is part manual and part automated. If asked if it has achieved its main
objective, then I'd say NO. But of course we should also trust government that they will be prepared for the next election and whatever shortcomings that was encountered in 2010 elections, then
those will serve as learning process which will eventually pave the way for an
honest, fully automated elections.
On the personal note, I have seen lapses in terms of
the system implementation but since this is just a baby step for the AES, then
it would be unfair for us to fully blame the concerned government agencies knowing
that a very good project study was done before implementing the said project
but the way I see it, the major problem comes out during the implementation
process itself. At the same time, the constitutional provision is somewhat “double bladed” provisions. It desires for a fully AES but it entertains the thought of failure because of the which is not suppose to be. Being the government one should be firm on its decisions and that no one is above the law as they say it. In general, partly it is a failure. To note, especially in Mindanao, there was no such thing as AES and the elections there was done manually and in some areas, the government have declared failure of elections due to election related incidents. We live in an imperfect society
and whoever leads the nation, there is and there will be an opposition. Ironic but
when PNoy was not yet elected, all seemed to be in unison shouting for a new
change and that its time to end the corrupt regimen of the Arroyo
administration and watching the news nowadays, they are still shouting in
unison..though with a different tune. Oust Pnoy. Really pathetic. Those people
were never contented. I believe we should give the administration the chance to prove itself especially that the main slogan of Pnoy is a honest and clean-slate governance. The previous election on my personal opinion was a bit of a failure but we learn from our mistakes. The government should
learn from its mistakes and I totally believe in the good governance pushed by Pnoy. He deserves a chance to show his capability and this could not be measured in his first 100 days of his term. We have given Gloria 6 years..and 6 years she have shown her cunning ability in
stealing peoples money, I guess Pnoy deserves a chance to prove his advocacy
for good governance.
the system implementation but since this is just a baby step for the AES, then
it would be unfair for us to fully blame the concerned government agencies knowing
that a very good project study was done before implementing the said project
but the way I see it, the major problem comes out during the implementation
process itself. At the same time, the constitutional provision is somewhat “double bladed” provisions. It desires for a fully AES but it entertains the thought of failure because of the which is not suppose to be. Being the government one should be firm on its decisions and that no one is above the law as they say it. In general, partly it is a failure. To note, especially in Mindanao, there was no such thing as AES and the elections there was done manually and in some areas, the government have declared failure of elections due to election related incidents. We live in an imperfect society
and whoever leads the nation, there is and there will be an opposition. Ironic but
when PNoy was not yet elected, all seemed to be in unison shouting for a new
change and that its time to end the corrupt regimen of the Arroyo
administration and watching the news nowadays, they are still shouting in
unison..though with a different tune. Oust Pnoy. Really pathetic. Those people
were never contented. I believe we should give the administration the chance to prove itself especially that the main slogan of Pnoy is a honest and clean-slate governance. The previous election on my personal opinion was a bit of a failure but we learn from our mistakes. The government should
learn from its mistakes and I totally believe in the good governance pushed by Pnoy. He deserves a chance to show his capability and this could not be measured in his first 100 days of his term. We have given Gloria 6 years..and 6 years she have shown her cunning ability in
stealing peoples money, I guess Pnoy deserves a chance to prove his advocacy
for good governance.
No comments:
Post a Comment